DEFENCE INVESTIGATIONS

Defence investigations in Italian criminal proceedings

Criminal defence is not limited to assessing evidence gathered by the prosecution: the defence may independently identify and obtain material relevant to factual reconstruction and the procedural strategy.

Italian criminal procedure allows defence counsel to carry out investigative activities aimed at identifying evidence favourable to the client, subject to the rules of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Such investigations may be particularly important where the prosecution file provides an incomplete picture, where existing statements require verification or where evidence may be lost with the passage of time.

The decision to conduct an investigation is not automatic. It must be assessed in light of the specific proceedings, the procedural stage and the possible effects of obtaining the material. A statement, a document or a site inspection is useful only when it forms part of a coherent defence strategy.

Interviews with persons with relevant knowledge

Defence counsel may identify persons able to provide relevant information and, where permitted, obtain statements or information from them. Before any interview, the person’s role, relationship with those involved and the concrete usefulness of the information sought must be assessed.

Documents, places and technical examinations

Defence investigations may include obtaining documents, inspecting locations or objects, photographic or technical reconstruction, and coordinating authorised private investigators and experts. Where proceedings involve digital data, accounting material, electronic devices or scientific evidence, prompt action may be important to preserve material that could change or be lost.

Defence investigations at different procedural stages

Defence investigations may be useful during preliminary investigations, in preparing for trial, on appeal and, where the legal requirements are met, in connection with an application for revision of a final conviction. Timing and method must be calibrated to the procedural stage and the aims of the defence.

Defence work

  • identification and interviewing of persons with relevant knowledge;
  • requests for and acquisition of documents;
  • site inspections and factual verification;
  • coordination with authorised private investigators and technical experts;
  • collection and preservation of evidence in accordance with procedural rules;
  • assessment of its procedural use and the appropriate time for disclosure or filing.

Investigative work is planned after reviewing the material already available and, where necessary, integrated into the wider defence strategy. The practice is based in Milan and can coordinate defence investigations elsewhere in Italy.